Persius...I've said, in times past, that expecting too much is dangerous! There will be a lot of people disappointed, no matter what. It's the nature of the beast! And setting Brad up on a pedestal isn't too hard! He's earned at least a small one from many of the noted and published authors on the subject of gaming and developing, yet if you talk to him irl, his enthusiasm and joy, as well as his humble attitude, earns him another notch!
And yes...I stamped out quite a few of my own fires that were coming up as I wrote the first draft of this, so if you see singe marks and smell a little smoke....sorry!
I quit reading the thread. I will agree it's a waste of space. I don't think anyone should be breaking the NDA, but perhaps some unknown folks could be asked to give their opinions, both good and bad, and publish it under the Sigil banner. I don't agree with singling out one known player/friend for that job. It creates stress on both parties, can cause some hard feelings and can be looked at as a little more than biased, so it's not fair to anyone. But a group effort would be very interesting. It would be nice to hear "reviews" from people in beta who have opinions but are sticking to the contract!
Who knows? Maybe that will happen, too.
We'll see.